Illinois Criminal Defense Lawyer

Call for a Free Criminal Defense Legal Consultation

(888) 205-9314

  • Home
  • IL Criminal Charges
  • Illinois Criminal Code and Laws
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Blog

ACLU Suing Over Illinois Eavesdropping Act

August 23, 2010

In Illinois it’s illegal to record a police officer acting in the line of duty even though they can record you. According to Adam Schwartz with the American Civil Liberties Union, “It’s an unfair and destructive double standard.” In an effort to prove that the ACLU filed suit in federal court to challenge that law.

The Illinois Eavesdropping Act makes it a crime to record any conversation without consent from everyone present. The ACLU states the act violates the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and that people should be able to record (especially police) while acting in the line of duty.

Many people have had or heard about negative experiences with law enforcement. This distrust of law enforcement paired with the increase in cell phones equipped with video cameras has led to n increasing number of people recording their own and other people’s interactions with the police.

Case in point: According to the Chicago Tribune, a car load of people were confronted by officers in a McDonald’s parking lot. One 23 year old passenger began recording the encounter with his phone because he was slightly “suspicious” of the officer. When the cops realized what he was doing, the man was cuffed and placed into the patrol car.

Another passenger recorded the man’s arrest. Both were charged with felony eavesdropping, though both plead down to a misdemeanor. They were also required to apologize to the officers.

Too many acts of police brutality and misconduct have been caught on camera for this Illinois law to stay on the books. Because the police are public servants, paid by taxpayers, their accountability should be monitored by the public. And if this includes recording interactions, I don’t see how that should be criminal.

Had the act of recording been paired with another criminal act, like impeding an investigation, criminal charges might have been relevant. But for the recording itself to be considered a criminal act seems to be over the top.

Similar laws exist in Massachusetts and Oregon, making only three total who ban recordings of public conversations in public places where there is no expectation of privacy and the conversation is audible by the average person. The fact that there is no expectation of privacy and the conversation is at such a volume that it can be heard by anyone seems to only support the notion that the ban is irrational if not Unconstitutional.

Not trusting the police is an all too common occurrence. This is unfortunate as the vast majority of law enforcement officers are ethical. But that doesn’t mean that they should be allowed this special status and exception to our first amendment protections.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Reddit

Filed Under: criminal law Tagged With: ACLU, laws, police, surveillance

Comments

  1. Jim Burger says

    October 8, 2010 at 1:01 pm

    I was falsely accused by the Oak Lawn police, if it weren’t for a digital voice recorder that I activated, I would be in prison right now because of fraudulent, fabricated filings by those police officers.

    The police are public servants and public employees, every employer in the state is allowed to video tape their employees, why shouldn’t we (the employers of the police) be allowed to video tape our employees (the police)?

  2. dave says

    October 8, 2010 at 1:11 pm

    Couldn’t agree more, Jim. The laws limiting videotaping the police only provide cover for bad cops. Decent cops acting reasonably shouldn’t be against this. Most people will always give the cops the benefit of the doubt when dealing with a clearly belligerent or out of control citizen, but it is all too easy for the police to abuse their authority.
    Against this we need to be protected.

    Thanks for commenting.

  3. mold damage adjuster says

    November 18, 2013 at 6:36 am

    hello!,I love your writing so much! share we keep in touch more approximately your article
    on AOL? I require a specialist on this house to unravel my problem.

    Maybe that is you! Looking ahead to peer you.

Free Consultation

Contact our attorneys for a free legal case evaluation on any criminal charge by calling:


(888) 205-9314


Receive our free legal defense consultation and case evaluation. We'll explain what you are facing in plain language, and tell you how we can help.

Copyright © 2021 Get Lawyer Leads, Inc.
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. This is not a law firm or referral service and does not provide legal advice. This is a free matching service only, claim reviews will be performed by a third party attorney. An attorney-client relationship is not formed when you submit the form and you are under no obligation to retain a lawyer who contacts you through this service. Services are not available in all states.